Mastercraft or Malibu

[turbonine]

I know there have been threads like "If Tiges didn't exists which boat would you own" but I wanted to narrow it down even further. If you couldn't have a Tige, would you rather be in a Mastercraft or a Malibu?

[balair]

no tige.....AHHHHH!!!!!!!

[Tanner]

How bout a centurion?... LOL

[ragboy]

MC for me. I hate the tiny bow and the illusion tower, otherwise, great boat. I love the front ladder, video display, and anchor holder in bow in the X45. I would choose the X45 over 247.

[rogersbm82]

Mc as well for me but let's hope it doesn't come down to that. lol

[harv]

MC for me... Malibu SUCKS!!! lol

[scoot18]

I could do either one. Some things I like on one better than the other and that goes for both of them, they are both fine boats. Happy with my tige` for now though............ The only thing I wish my tige had was the fuel economy of my prior boat.

[KonaKing]

X45

[samw]

Mastercraft, My brother-n-law has a mc X45 it's very nice.
(My Tige puts out a better wake)

[Timmy!]

MC for me. I hate the tiny bow and the illusion tower, otherwise, great boat. I love the front ladder, video display, and anchor holder in bow in the X45. I would choose the X45 over 247.

Exactly the same reason for me.

[Fast1911]

Since I already own an old MC, I think I would stick with them.

[chpthril]

Since we are not real hard-core boarders, it would not be the brand with the best wake, except for maybe surf wake though, got have a great one. There is not much about the MC's that I really like......looks, seating, too much bling, They just dont do anything for me, kinda like the hefty, zit faced brace-face in school, she may have made the best girlfriend, etc, but kinda hard to get bast the looks

[jwanck11]

I like the old MC ski boats.

[da.bell]

MB...

Probably the new 21 foot Tomcat.

[NICKYPOO]

X45. I actually really like the helm in the Bu, but that's it. Well, that and their customer service from the factory. Top notch from what I understand. Other than that, I've tried to surf several new Bu's and I can't stand 'em. That is the ugliest surf wake I've ever seen. I hate that stupid tower. The 21xti handles pretty good, but I don't like the way the 23's handle. Super thin hulls as well. They have really nice wakeboarding wakes, but I could care less. Just not very impressed with them over all.

I've never even been in any MC of any kind although I was seriously considering buying an X9 before I found my tigger. Kind of funny considering I've been on the water all my life. Just worked out that way. Thank God I didn't. Those things are tiny. The X45 does impress me with its lay out and overall appearance (except that ridiculous looking dash and jenky tower).

So I guess if I had to choose between the two, Supra.