Announcement

Collapse
No announcement yet.

You ever swap one kind of fender for another on your trailer?

Collapse
X
 
  • Filter
  • Time
  • Show
Clear All
new posts

    You ever swap one kind of fender for another on your trailer?

    I went to Lake Powell last week. Will be posting pics soon to document the trip, had a great time.

    The road from here to the Lake is a 2 lane freeway and temps are over 100 degrees. The road is somewhat rough, and I suffered a blowout. No big deal...sort of. The trailer tires were manufactured in May of 06, so although they have been kept inside, they are getting old, as far as trailer tires go.

    Mastercraft makes their own trailers and thought it would be way cool to have fiberglass fenders. They look cool, but didn't they ever think that you might get a blowout? Anyway, the right rear tire blew out and I did not notice it in time to stop it from whipping around and destroying the rear 6 inches of fender. The pieces were missing by the time I realized what had happened. The rear portion included a backup and running light, those are scattered along the highway as well.

    I went to a local body shop and asked them to repair it. The rear portion of the fender has a variety of swirls and curved edges that are going to be very hard to make match the other side. He was reluctant to do something that won't match and he suggested I just get a new fender from the manufacturer.

    I called the dealer to see about ordering a new fender...$818 plus shipping from Tennessee to Utah. I am sure a 6 foot long fender is going to be a lot to ship, plus the new lights and then my trouble to get the old one unbolted and the new one bolted on. Between all that and the new tire as well, I am looking at 1K for a flat tire.

    So that has me thinking about other options. A metal fender would be nice, and a whole lot easier to repair next time I get a flat. For the price of a fiberglass fender, I could invest a whole lot in this project.

    A local trailer shop has alluminum fenders that are less than $200. Trouble is that they go down further than the current fenders and they also don't have anything that would cover the trailer steps that are located in front and behind the fender well. The local auto body guy sent me there and suggested he could bolt them on and shave off the front and back and make it work. I would throw some gator grip on there and have something that might be better than what I started with.

    Anyone else ever thought of something so nuts? I have posted on the MC forum, but it is generally taboo over there to think you can do something better than MC does it. Also, if you have done something non-MC to the boat, then it would hurt resale to someone who thinks that MC is the one and only way.

    So....am I crazy to think I could swap out the fenders for some chromed out ones? They would look better, IMO and will never cost me $900 to fix when I get my next blowout.

    On a separate note, the dry weight of the boat and trailer gets fairly high for tires with a load range C. This also applies to all of you guys with 24V and Ve and RZ4's. Then take into account that the 90 gallon gas tank is full and all the gear and you are pushing it for sure. There is only 1 tire in the universe that is 14 inches in diameter that can bump you up to a load range D, the KUMHO 857. I am considering that too. The summers here are usually 105+ during the day and I am sure the road is a lot hotter than that, so tires really take a beating. So I am considering upgrading the tires to help decrease the risk of another blowout.

    Forgive my combination of ranting and asking for help. Let me know what you think.

    One other option is to cut off the rear of the fender on both sides so my local shop can make them match a straight squared end. That is probably most cost effective in the short term. But then I still have crappy fiberglass fenders that are going to splinter on my next blowout. It will be time to sell next summer...maybe it would hold until then.
    Last edited by talltigeguy; 06-17-2010, 12:48 AM.
    Be excellent to one another.

    #2
    Funny you should mention this Tall, I just had a blow out as well! Fortunately for me, the damage was 20 mins lost time to change it out. Thanks for keeping the spare in great condition and aired up, I hadn't checked the spare since I bought the boat. Oops! I opted to go ahead and purchase all 5 new tires and of course a load range C. The goodyear dealer did have D range tires, but they were x2 the price. I opted to stay with the exact tire that was factory but filled them all with nitrogen this time. Believe it or not, I can tell the difference in towing the old vs new tires. Good luck with your trailer!

    Comment


      #3
      Tall, I can't wait to hear more about the trip.
      I would definately go with the stronger non-plastic fenders.
      And I wish that trailer mfgrs would build a little more safety factor into their designs. These boats should really have four 15" tires. I would be the first willing to pay a couple hundred more to have it done right. The Extreme trailer on my last Tige had non-trailer (passenger car) tires that didn't meet the weight rating on the trailer. I had to threaten them with a claim to the "trailer manufacturers association" that they were so proud of being a member, before they would swap out my tires with legit ones. Age, heat, bad roads, extra weight for longer trips, all add up to problems that are bound to happen.

      Comment


        #4
        do you have a local fiber shop to do repairs to trailer?
        -
        second what is your ins ded. that should be covered damages for the trailer fender, probably not the tire itself, but for the trailer.
        - also some companys will have a trailer only damage ded.
        - also maybe have ins pay for fiber and then switch out to metal fenders anyway.
        postup some pixs on whatever you do.

        Comment


          #5
          If you go the insurance route, also make sure and look all over the entire boat as they tend to get a little scuffed up. Check your graphics, etc.! It's all covered. A buddy of mine had his graphics on his sea ray scuffed up. To replace one side of his graphics the manufacturer wanted $1200. He talked the insurance guy into letting him switch to a custom graphic that was cheaper for them, an in return he got the company to waive his deductible.
          Being a major OU fan and a staunch conservative.... I am perpetually vexed w/ the conundrum of who to hate more. Obama or the Univ. of Saxet.

          Comment


            #6
            Originally posted by yllw20 View Post
            do you have a local fiber shop to do repairs to trailer?
            -
            second what is your ins ded. that should be covered damages for the trailer fender, probably not the tire itself, but for the trailer.
            - also some companys will have a trailer only damage ded.
            - also maybe have ins pay for fiber and then switch out to metal fenders anyway.
            postup some pixs on whatever you do.
            My insurance deductible is $500, so I guess it might be worth doing, but I hate to do that for fear they will jack my rates.

            The local shop thinks they cannot match it perfectly to the other side because of all of the irregular corners...and they can't just piece it together because the parts are missing.

            Originally posted by Tanner View Post
            If you go the insurance route, also make sure and look all over the entire boat as they tend to get a little scuffed up. Check your graphics, etc.! It's all covered. A buddy of mine had his graphics on his sea ray scuffed up. To replace one side of his graphics the manufacturer wanted $1200. He talked the insurance guy into letting him switch to a custom graphic that was cheaper for them, an in return he got the company to waive his deductible.
            Good thinking. The rear of the boat did have some tire scuffs on it that I was worried about being permanent, but they came right out with some rubbing compound wax combination. I can't find any other damage. I could consider the backup light too, but that really is only going to be $30.

            Originally posted by Bad05 View Post
            Funny you should mention this Tall, I just had a blow out as well! Fortunately for me, the damage was 20 mins lost time to change it out. Thanks for keeping the spare in great condition and aired up, I hadn't checked the spare since I bought the boat. Oops! I opted to go ahead and purchase all 5 new tires and of course a load range C. The goodyear dealer did have D range tires, but they were x2 the price. I opted to stay with the exact tire that was factory but filled them all with nitrogen this time. Believe it or not, I can tell the difference in towing the old vs new tires. Good luck with your trailer!
            Bad05,

            Here is some fun reading for you in case you never saw it...some history on your trailer. This is how it got the metal valve stems. It is kind of long, but then gets interesting again at post #58.

            http://www.tigeowners.com/forum/show...al+valve+stems

            I will be doing a little looking at trailer fenders tonight while I sit here and watch the NBA finals.
            Be excellent to one another.

            Comment


              #7
              Good history on the trailer. I do disagree with there not being a benefit from Nitrogen filled tires though, oh well, each to their own. BTW, those sure are some nice valve stems, the guys at Goodyear even asked me if I had them installed. I just said no, the guy before me probably did knowing him....thanks for proving me right! I looked at new rims/tires/fenders a while back but don't want to spend the money on a perfectly good setup. I think you should though....ha!

              Comment


                #8
                I think I could get it retrofitted to look like this:



                Probably for about the same price as a new fiberglass fender on just one side.

                I did find a place online that will sell me the new fiberglass fender for $604 instead of $818. You hate to dump your local dealer, but when they give you a markup like that, you sort of have to. Especially when I am talking about ordering something through them that they don't keep in stock. They make a phone call and push a few buttons and make that much money? Not me, if I can avoid it.
                Be excellent to one another.

                Comment


                  #9
                  Just wait till you see the price of those stainless fenders! LOL
                  Being a major OU fan and a staunch conservative.... I am perpetually vexed w/ the conundrum of who to hate more. Obama or the Univ. of Saxet.

                  Comment


                    #10
                    Stainless Steel for Steel

                    I have an 02 Extreme that came with my 23V. The tire size is 235/60/15. It is a very odd size for a trailer tire and up until Carlisle built a D range tire, I would only get about 1 season out of C's...The Carlisles are OK, but I get maybe 3 years out of them. First pic is what happened with the latest blowout...I had one like this a few years back on the other side and replace the stainless at a cost of 400 bucks..

                    Not this time! Until I can take my welder and plasma cutter to this thing this winter, so I can put a 225/75/15 load range E tire on, I am replacing the stainless with a painted steel fender. Cost, about 250 bucks less. I don't care at this point the fenders don't match. Like I say, I am going to rebuild the trailer this winter to accept normal size trailer tires that are widely available, just like Extreme SHOULD HAVE!




                    Last edited by Billua; 06-19-2010, 12:44 AM.
                    Boating Lake Mead since 2000

                    Comment


                      #11
                      Originally posted by Tanner View Post
                      Just wait till you see the price of those stainless fenders! LOL
                      How about $548 for a pair...not just one. Seems better to me and several other places are in the same ballpark.

                      http://www.pacifictrailers.com/polis...ailer-fenders/
                      Be excellent to one another.

                      Comment

                      Working...
                      X